Skip to main content

Commentary: The quest for crowdfunding enters a complicated, but critical phase


Since President Obama signed the Jumpstart Our Business Startups Act last spring, the most successful crowdfunding campaign — for an e-paper wristwatch called Pebble Watch — raised $10 million. Another campaign — this one for a video game, raised $6.3 million from 90,000 fans online — shows that companies with innovative products and services can raise significant amounts of money online.

In about six months, the beleaguered Securities and Exchange Commission will put forward rules that will govern how companies can raise equity capital using crowdfunding.

It has been slow going. The SEC, staggered by its role in the financial crisis, is extraordinarily cautious now. The agency remains under the influence of the industry it regulates, which is frightened by crowdfunding. Industry officials have built obstacles in the SEC’s path to creating crowdfunding rules.

Critics of crowdfunding say that the risk of fraud is high, but their case is weak given that individual dollar investment amounts allowed under the JOBS Act are so small that it would take hundreds of years for crowdfunding to cost the American people the $17 trillion they lost at the height of the financial crisis.
Further, the risk of fraud can be managed by any number of financial instruments designed to do so. Supporters of the movement, for instance, have developed something called the crowdfunding put option, which would allow investors to sell securities back to the seller if fraud is uncovered.

Participants are also likely to sound the alarm if they spot problems. Supporters already have uncovered a potential flaw in the crowdfunding process that might give rise to significant fraud. Rather than discuss this publicly, we have warned the two largest crowdfunding platforms. We will wait to spell out what that flaw is, since we do not want to encourage frauds and seek to protect this new marketplace.

In other words, we (supporters of the crowdfunding movement) got this.

Here is what I think the SEC must do now: Broaden the base. At its forum on small-business capital formation last month, where crowdfunding rules were discussed, the SEC did not have a single African American on any panel. It is important to get participation and perspectives from many communities.
Currently, securities lawyers, another group affected by crowdfunding, have a stranglehold on the rules process. The SEC needs to, again, get input from multiple stakeholders, not just the legal community. This is a time for flexible, open and market-based crowdfunding rules and standards.

The SEC also must be willing to stand up to financial industry interest groups, which also threatened by crowdfunding and have obstructed action.

The JOBS Act is designed to reopen American capital markets to small companies, in part via crowdfunding. Like open source software, crowdfunding is simply open source financing. The regulations required by the JOBS Act are clear.

So is the task before the SEC. Let’s hope the agency doesn’t take longer and make this more complicated than it needs to be.


William Michael Cunningham is a D.C.-based economist and social investing advisor. He is the author of “The JOBS Act: Crowdfunding for Small Businesses and Startups.”


Online at: http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/capitalbusiness/commentary-the-quest-for-crowdfunding-enters-a-complicated-but-critical-phase/2012/12/23/d15ef280-4939-11e2-ad54-580638ede391_print.html

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Crowdfunding heads to Georgetown

So first Fundrise raises $31Million for real estate crowdfunding.  Now Realty Mogul, a real estate crowdfunding platform, responds quickly with a rare opportunity to be a part of a $31.8 million project in the exclusive Georgetown neighborhood of Washington DC. #crowdfundrealestate Realty Mogul, along with   JOSS Realty Partners ( "JOSS" ) , is introducing the Georgetown Plaza to the crowdfunding world. This 150,097 square foot   Class B office building is  located on Wisconsin Avenue, Washington DC's major north-south artery and half a mile north of Georgetown University's main campus and Georgetown University Hospital. The primary objective of this investment crowdfunding campaign is to acquire, lease-up, and reposition the office building before reselling. In this crowdfunding transaction, Realty Mogul investors will hold a partnership equity stake in Realty Mogul 19, LLC.   Realty Mogul 19, LLC will subsequently invest in 2233 Wisconsin NY Member L

Crowdfunding Accounting 101 - Revenue Recognition in Crowdfunding

A start-up using crowd funding to create a product is different from a normal company. The start-up has cash inflows from donations but does not have a product, yet. In this situation, we recommend using completed-contract method to recognize revenue. Under this way of thinking, we assume the start-up is akin to a project or a long-term contract. The crowdfunding company will find it difficult to estimate the revenue from crowdfunders and, hence, the cost of rewards or perks. Under International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and GAAP guidelines, if the firm cannot reliably measure the outcome of the project, revenue should be recognized based on contract costs. These costs should be expensed when incurred. Profit is recognized only at the completion of the project. In summary, for crowdfunding companies, revenue, expense, and profit are recognized only when the crowdfunded product is actually manufactured. 1 For example, assume that AAA Corp. wants to manufacture bicyc

Why we are so optimistic about crowdfunding for minorities

Dr. Mark Dean - On the IBM team that developed PC : "Mark E. Dean (born March 2, 1957) is an African American inventor and a computer engineer. He led the team that developed the ISA bus, and he led the design team responsible for creating the first one-gigahertz computer processor chip. Dean has also helped in the early development of the computer keyboard. He holds three of IBM's original nine PC patents." Jesse Russell , recognized father of digital cellular technology: "Jesse Eugene Russell (b April 26, 1948) is an African-American inventor and one of the visionaries’ whose innovative perspectives profoundly influenced the wireless communications industry, (a) driver of growth in the 21st century. Trained as an electrical engineer at Tennessee State University and Stanford University , and recognized globally as a thought-leader, technology expert and inventor in the field of wireless communication for over 20 years.." Emmitt McHenry , Founder of Ne